A Prayer for the Dying – Watch Johnny Flynn and John C. Reilly in the trailer for the new Indie Western

In 1870, the town of Friendship, Wisconsin, is enduring a dry, hot summer. The small town revolves around Jacob Hansen (Johnny Flynn), a hero of the American Civil War who, in spite of his many accomplishments, is unable to cast off the violence and darkness of his past as a soldier. Feeling compelled to atone for the wrongs he has committed, Jacob takes on the responsibility not only of providing for his young family but also of serving as sheriff, undertaker, & pastor for Friendship. He thus considers the town to be under his protection – a claim that comes to haunt him when Friendship is hit by an epidemic that the town’s doctor (John C. Reilly) cannot contain. As every decision becomes a choice between two evils, Jacob is increasingly haunted by his war-ridden past. It is unclear how much longer he can continue in his self-imposed role as protector or whether he will ever be able to forgive himself for what he’s done.

Based on the novel of the same name by Stewart O’Nan, the film is directed by Dara Van Dusen and stars Johnny Flynn, John C. Reilly, Kristine Kujath Thorp, Gustav Lindh, Hilton Pelser and Andrew Whipp.

Thank you for supporting Live for Films (LFF) when you order using an affiliate link. As an Amazon Associate, LFF earns from qualifying purchases. If you are using an ad blocker, you will not see the link.

A Prayer For The Dying will premiere at the 2026 Berlin Film Festival.

Thanks to First Showing and Berlinale for the news.